Sorry for the delay in my reply, it took me a while to sort my preferences in order,,,
1) The gang gets turned into various species (some sharpteeth, some not) and have to consider how to adapt or change back. This one is my favorite and the one I’m most enthusiastic about because of the possibilities it presents, to put it simply. While I’m fine with either outcome of the story, I think that having them stay as they are would be a great way for them to adapt and create new lives for themselves.
2) Petrie wished for brothers and sisters who were not jerks...the gang were less than impressed when they woke up as flyer’s the next morning. This scenario could be interesting, especially since there are various kinds of flyers the gang could turn into!
3) Transformations happen, but it extends to some of the valley adults as well.
Could also be interesting to see how the adults would react to the transformation.
4) Chomper gets his wish to be with his friends as a fellow leaf eater...but ironically they all get turned into sharpteeth at the same time. This definitely sounds intriguing enough, but I’d be interested to see how Chomper and his friends adapt.
5) Same idea as the original RP: the gang gets turned into sharpteeth of various kinds are kicked out of the valley. I could get behind this, but as Sovereign said, it could only hold my interest if it went a different direction than The Seven Hunters.
6) Petrie and Ducky get swapped (either in species or body) Hmm...not feeling too enthusiastic about this one, as it might end rather quickly and wouldn’t be as action-filled.
7) The gang gets cursed to change into a new species every few nights and must adapt until they can find a way to break the curse. I feel that this would be too complicated and hard to keep up with.